http://209.114.50.211/forums/showthread.php?s=bcc9573da2e28c121b81ff02ced58462&t=119840&page=2
Nikon axes comfort women photo exhibition
2 Weeks Ago #1
shiro_kuro
Registered User
shiro_kuro is offline
Join Date: Jul 2006
Location: Hawaii
Posts: 330
Nikon axes comfort women photo exhibition
Ahn Sehong had his Photo exhibit canceled By Nikon
Here is a link to the full story :
http://ajw.asahi.com/article/behind_news/AJ201205240049
"Nikon Corp. officials canceled a photo exhibition of former "comfort women" in Tokyo but denied the decision was the result of angry protests that spread from the Internet to the camera manufacturer."
Images can be seen here
http://ahnsehong.com/gallery/layerbylayer_2012/
__________________
ShiroKuro
“Once in a while you can get shown the light in the strangest of places if you look at it right.”
Robert Hunter
2 Weeks Ago #2
kbg32
neo-romanticist
kbg32 is offline
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: New York, New York
Posts: 3,539
It's a shame.
__________________
Keith
http://keithgoldstein.me/
http://www.rangefinderforum.com/phot...00&ppuser=1012
www.pbase.com/keithbg
2 Weeks Ago #3
Lund
Registered User
Lund is offline
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 53
Nationalism is often a very ugly thing. As any strong us/them ideology.
2 Weeks Ago #4
Sejanus.Aelianus
Registered User
Sejanus.Aelianus is offline
Join Date: Feb 2012
Posts: 159
I worry that an influential block of Japanese just can't come to terms with the realities of history.
__________________
Sometimes out of focus but never out of bounds...
pIXIS
2 Weeks Ago #5
Roger Hicks
Registered User
Roger Hicks is offline
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Aquitaine
Posts: 15,082
Gosh, what a surprise.
Cheers,
R.
__________________
Now even more free photography information on www.rogerandfrances.com
2 Weeks Ago #6
Robert Lai
Registered User
Robert Lai is offline
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 279
This persistent denial of the Japanese by the crimes of the Imperial Army before and during WWII is probably the number one reason why they continue to be resented and hated in Asia.
I had family in Burma, China, and Singapore during the war.
The brutality of the Japanese was no propaganda. It was real.
It took some courage of Nikon to allow the exhibition to be scheduled in the first place. Then, cowardice took over.
2 Weeks Ago #7
FrankS
Moderator
FrankS is offline
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Great White North
Age: 55
Posts: 15,749
The japanese are not the only group guilty of brutality during war.
And not all Japanese are guilty of this brutality, or of not accepting it as truth.
__________________
“Believe nothing, no matter where you read it or who has said it, not even if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.” – quote
RFF gallery: http://www.rangefinderforum.com/phot...y.php?cat=7602
2 Weeks Ago #8
Leigh Youdale
Registered User
Leigh Youdale is offline
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Sydney, Australia
Posts: 1,634
True, Frank. But on the scale of 1-10?
__________________
Fuji X10
Leica M6
Bessa R4A
Rolleiflex (3): E2 Planar 2.8, WA & Tele
Nikkormat FTn (2)
2 Weeks Ago #9
flip
残念でした又どうぞ
flip is offline
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Kobe, Japan
Posts: 935
Quote:
Originally Posted by Leigh Youdale
True, Frank. But on the scale of 1-10?
I think his point is that if you pick your people and moments in time, every culture has produced more nastiness than the human race can be proud of.
I, for one, say shame on the humans. Long live the peaceful apes.
__________________
M2, please come home.
2 Weeks Ago #10
FrankS
Moderator
FrankS is offline
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Great White North
Age: 55
Posts: 15,749
On a scale of 1 to 10 how racist is the dislike of a whole race of people, most of whom are individuals innocent of the cause of the hatred?
This is no longer a photographic discussion. There is a forum for this.
__________________
“Believe nothing, no matter where you read it or who has said it, not even if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.” – quote
RFF gallery: http://www.rangefinderforum.com/phot...y.php?cat=7602
2 Weeks Ago #11
JMQ
Registered User
JMQ is offline
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Northern New Jersey
Posts: 192
There is a memorial dedicated to the Comfort Women here in Northern NJ, in the town of Palisades Park. Just recently, the Japanese Consulate tried to have it removed. When that didn't work, members of the Japanese government came, and also tried. When the township refused to budge, they resorted to denial -- that the Comfort Women did so voluntarily. I applaud Palisades Park for standing up to what it believes.
2 Weeks Ago #12
JMQ
Registered User
JMQ is offline
Join Date: Jan 2010
Location: Northern New Jersey
Posts: 192
It's a shame that Nikon surrendered to cowardice or pressure. I looked at the link that ShiroKuro posted, and the images are powerful.
2 Weeks Ago #13
Frank Version Two
-
Frank Version Two is offline
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: near Rochester, New York, USA
Posts: 986
Thank goodness we have moderators to tell us how to think properly, some discussions would be too difficult for us primitives to handle.
The fact is, that more than any other modern First World country, the Japanese have managed to avoid and forget their history. Young Japanese get a filtered, distorted history of World War II and the run-up, which can't be good in the long run. Contrast that to the German experience.
2 Weeks Ago #14
FrankS
Moderator
FrankS is offline
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Great White North
Age: 55
Posts: 15,749
Think however you like Frankv2.
__________________
“Believe nothing, no matter where you read it or who has said it, not even if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.” – quote
RFF gallery: http://www.rangefinderforum.com/phot...y.php?cat=7602
2 Weeks Ago #15
Frontman
Registered User
Frontman is offline
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: 東京日本
Posts: 897
Since the end of the war, the Japanese have gradually whitewashed what happened. Textbooks and history books have become written in a more passive way, and subjects like comfort women, treatment of POWs, and Unit 731 are often not mentioned at all.
At every anniversary of the dropping of the atomic bombs there are protests and speeches by right-wing nuts screaming that the use of atomic weapons and the following US military occupation were unjustified. And if you were a student nowadays reading Japanese history as it is written, you would likely agree.
But my grandfather fought in the Pacific during the war for the entire duration. He fought the Japanese on the Philippines, and was one of the handful who were evacuated with General MacArthur. He later participated in the battle of Manila, and was present at the signing of the surrender on the battleship Missouri. After 4 years of fighting, he was one of only two survivors of the original troop deployed to the Pacific.
Comfort women were also used after the war, but they were intended to serve the US occupation force so as to prevent US soldiers from fraternizing with ordinary Japanese women.
There are Japanese who are quite honest about what happened during the war, and I have seen fights break out at the yakuza-organized right-wing rallies. Ordinary Japanese suffered under the former government before and during the war, and expected worse things to come after the surrender. To their surprise, the change brought about after the war was good. When I meet older Japanese who experienced the war and post war years and tell them that I am an American, they often thank me.
But other Japanese are ashamed of their history, and prefer that it not be brought up. This is wrong, it denies the sacrifices, good and bad, of those
who fought and suffered, making them all for nothing. I'm rather ashamed of Nikon for canceling this exhibit.
1 Week Ago #16
flip
残念でした又どうぞ
flip is offline
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Kobe, Japan
Posts: 935
Quote:
Originally Posted by Frank Version Two
Thank goodness we have moderators to tell us how to think properly, some discussions would be too difficult for us primitives to handle.
The fact is, that more than any other modern First World country, the Japanese have managed to avoid and forget their history. Young Japanese get a filtered, distorted history of World War II and the run-up, which can't be good in the long run. Contrast that to the German experience.
I'll be pedantic.
FACT: a piece of information presented as having objective reality.
It would be difficult to empirically prove to me that the Japanese whitewash *more* than the U.S..
The world is full of nations and organizations that behave badly. Is this conversation making it any better? If you think having the exhibit shown would make it more so, I think a better use of energy would be to write to those who made the decision and voice your disappointment rather than to argue about who should win the international turd of the century competition.
Positive, not negative, action.
__________________
M2, please come home.
1 Week Ago #17
Sejanus.Aelianus
Registered User
Sejanus.Aelianus is offline
Join Date: Feb 2012
Posts: 159
I rather think that any conversation, where people state their views and listen to those of others, will help to make things better. Of course, if no-one listens, then the whole thing is a waste of electrons.
__________________
Sometimes out of focus but never out of bounds...
pIXIS
1 Week Ago #18
Haigh
Gary Haigh
Haigh is offline
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 864
I guess the Japanese do not want to know about their darker side in WW2.
1 Week Ago #19
Haigh
Gary Haigh
Haigh is offline
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 864
Some years ago we were watching a TV program on one such woman and when we saw on TV her house we recognised it as being in our district. That brave woman told of her ordeal as a forced comfort woman and it was degrading to say the very least, both mentally and physically. She had kept it quiet for decades but then I guess as part of the healing process went public.
A remarkable woman and as it turned out, a with a remarkable husband.
1 Week Ago #20
steveniphoto
Registered User
steveniphoto is offline
Join Date: May 2012
Posts: 31
i saw charlie kirk post this too. i was very disappointed.. i think these women deserve to have their story shared.
__________________
visit my blog
1 Week Ago #21
FrankS
Moderator
FrankS is offline
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Great White North
Age: 55
Posts: 15,749
Quote:
Originally Posted by Haigh
I guess the Japanese do not want to know about their darker side in WW2.
It would be more accurate to say that some Japanese people do not wish to be reminded of some aspects of the war.
General, broad-brush statements about a large group or whole race of people are certain to be incorrect at the individual level.
__________________
“Believe nothing, no matter where you read it or who has said it, not even if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.” – quote
RFF gallery: http://www.rangefinderforum.com/phot...y.php?cat=7602
1 Week Ago #22
David Hughes
Registered User
David Hughes is offline
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 1,554
Hi,
The trouble is that history usually gets distorted, often by politicians. Just look how many believe those stories that the USSR looted Contax. Worst still, look how many refuse to accept, or just cannot believe, that the USSR and the USA were fighting on the same side.
One of the things I like about RFF is that so many here have open minds and act reasonably. But I guess that's because us film and RF users are yet another minority and know how hard it is to get the truth over to some people...
Regards, David
1 Week Ago #23
noimmunity
Hy Times
noimmunity is offline
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Lyon/Taipei
Posts: 1,922
A pity that Nikon did not go through with the exhibit. But then again, it would have been a little like Daimler Benz putting on an exhibit of photos of the Warsaw Ghetto.
The real problem of course is that the historical legacy of 'comfort women' remains largely unresolved.
Part of the reason this legacy remains unresolved is because of complicity from the postwar US-occupation. As in so many other areas of Japanese life, where elements of the wartime establishment were mobilized to support US policy of domination in Asia, comfort women were used on a very wide scale by US occupation forces during the initial stages of occupation.
__________________
jon 小強
now imag(in)ing with Fuji 71112 (FG 80D), Eastman 5222 (Double X), Fuji RVP50, Kodak KAF-10500 (M8) and the Fuji X-Trans CMOS (X-Pro1) through CV, ZM, Leica, Konica, Fuji, and Rollei glass.
my neglected flickr
Flickr
1 Week Ago #24
sevo
Fokutorendaburando
sevo is offline
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: Frankfurt, Germany
Posts: 2,843
Quote:
Originally Posted by noimmunity
A pity that Nikon did not go through with the exhibit. But then again, it would have been a little like Daimler Benz putting on an exhibit of photos of the Warsaw Ghetto
German corporations generally will support exhibitions of that type - companies of Daimler-Benz scale usually even have researched and published their own involvement in Nazi age atrocities, and have some program to at least symbolically compensate their victims.
1 Week Ago #25
noimmunity
Hy Times
noimmunity is offline
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Lyon/Taipei
Posts: 1,922
Quote:
Originally Posted by sevo
German corporations generally will support exhibitions of that type - companies of Daimler-Benz scale usually even have researched and published their own involvement in Nazi age atrocities, and have some program to at least symbolically compensate their victims.
Thank you for the clarification and for insisting on the often merely symbolic nature of reparations.
Once again, the issue of U.S. complicity is significant.
Quote:
The International Military Tribunal for the Far East established in 1946 was supposed to be a counterpart to the Nuremberg Tribunal... Conspicuously, absent from the tribunal's list of defendants were representatives of the zaibatsus. The situation of Japanese national guilt is complicated by the seeming pardon of the Japanese Emperor Hirohito for war crimes and the nuclear annihilation of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Further American intervention against Communism in East Asia required a stable Japan. Prosecuting former militarists would harm the Japanese economic recovery and was contrary to the American national interest.
from http://www.fantompowa.net/Flame/levy...war_crimes.htm
Although Nikon was involved in the armaments industry, I have not read of any allegations of forced or slave labor. There is documentation however of widespread used of forced Korean labor in Japan during the war.
__________________
jon 小強
now imag(in)ing with Fuji 71112 (FG 80D), Eastman 5222 (Double X), Fuji RVP50, Kodak KAF-10500 (M8) and the Fuji X-Trans CMOS (X-Pro1) through CV, ZM, Leica, Konica, Fuji, and Rollei glass.
my neglected flickr
Flickr
#26
redisburning
Registered User
redisburning is online now
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 602
why do the yakuza organize nationalist rallies?
my understanding was that they grew out of the immediate post-war period. what is it to them that the books accurately describe what the military did?
the photographer is a brave man; a Korean living in Japan trying to shed light on a squelched part of Japanese history. If I had my own gallery I would be proud to offer him space to show his photographs.
__________________
http://www.flickr.com/photos/pmcmanis/
1 Week Ago #27
jonmanjiro
BFNM
jonmanjiro is offline
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Yokohama, Japan
Posts: 3,161
Quote:
"This is basically Nikon's self-censorship. Is it all right for a large corporation like Nikon to permit such a wimpy reaction?" Takei asked.
'Various reasons' halted sex slave exhibit: Nikon
Tuesday, May 29, 2012
http://www.japantimes.co.jp/text/nn20120529a3.html
Nikon Corp. canceled its planned photo exhibition of wartime sex slaves for "various reasons," the major camera maker has announced.
Although Nikon declined to state the specific reasons for the cancellation, a company spokesman admitted it received a number of complaints about the event, which was to be held from June 26 to July 9 at Shinjuku Nikon Salon in Tokyo's Shinjuku Ward. The photos were taken by South Korean photographer Ahn Sehong.
"We received complaints by mail and telephone, but we cannot comment on how many complaints we got or the nature of the complaints," said the spokesman, who asked not to be named.
Euphemistically known in Japan as the "comfort women," the young women and girls, in large part of Korean origin, were forced into sexual slavery for the Imperial armed forces during the war.
The atrocity has been a major source of diplomatic friction in Asia, especially between South Korea and Japan.
In 1993, Yohei Kono, then chief Cabinet secretary, issued a statement acknowledging the state played a role in the wartime brothel program and offered an apology. But the government has refused to pay individual redress.
The Japan Visual Journalist Association is preparing a statement slamming Nikon for violating freedom of expression, said Takeharu Watai, one of the three representatives of the group.
"This is basically Nikon's self-censorship. Is it all right for a large corporation like Nikon to permit such a wimpy reaction?" Takei asked.
Nikon called on the public for photos to display at the Shinjuku salon late last year and decided to hold the exhibition of Ahn's comfort women photos earlier this year, the spokesman said.
On May 21, Internet bulletin boards 2channel and Yahoo Chiebukuro Q&A forum had postings on the event, which had the obvious intention of soliciting protests. The 2channel posts have a phone number and detailed information on Ahn, an Aichi Prefecture resident, and called on others to lodge protests targeting the photographer.
Nikon decided to cancel the photo exhibition the following day, the spokesman said.
Military Sexual Slavery by Japan During the Second World War, a group seeking to raise awareness of the sex slaves, released a statement May 24 that said: "Ahn Sehong does not accept the cancellation of the photo exhibition, which (Nikon) cannot explain the reasons for. The world-renowned Nikon's reaction damages one photographer's honor and will be known by the global media."
In contrast to Nikon's decision, the city of Yokkaichi, Mie Prefecture, will stick to its plan to hold an exhibition of Ahn's comfort women photos at a community hall from 2 to 4:30 p.m. on June 10.
"We have received some complaints. But (Ahn) asked to use the hall and we confirmed there is no violation of city ordinances. Thus there is no reason to reject his request," Yokkaichi official Takuya Sugawa said.
__________________
flickr
1 Week Ago #28
Frontman
Registered User
Frontman is offline
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: 東京日本
Posts: 897
Quote:
Originally Posted by redisburning
why do the yakuza organize nationalist rallies?
my understanding was that they grew out of the immediate post-war period. what is it to them that the books accurately describe what the military did?
the photographer is a brave man; a Korean living in Japan trying to shed light on a squelched part of Japanese history. If I had my own gallery I would be proud to offer him space to show his photographs.
The Yakuza go back quite far in Japanese history, with references to them occurring as early as the 17th century.
If you spend any time in a large Japanese city you'll eventually see and hear the speaker trucks blaring old military airs. The trucks are usually pAinted black, and are marked with the chrysanthemum seal and/or old battle flags. These nuts generally drive around in noisy convoys, stopping in front of the occasion train station, government office building, or immigration office were jack-booted thugs in smart uniforms with swastikas on their shoulders will rant against good and normalcy.
The Yakuza usually spend most of their time breaking legs, pimping prostitutes, or skimming the profits of their more "legitimate" enterprises. Being right-wing nuts is a part-time occupation for them.
1 Week Ago #29
Nikon Bob
camera hunter & gatherer
Nikon Bob is offline
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 3,722
Quote:
Originally Posted by Frontman
The Yakuza go back quite far in Japanese history, with references to them occurring as early as the 17th century.
If you spend any time in a large Japanese city you'll eventually see and hear the speaker trucks blaring old military airs. The trucks are usually pAinted black, and are marked with the chrysanthemum seal and/or old battle flags. These nuts generally drive around in noisy convoys, stopping in front of the occasion train station, government office building, or immigration office were jack-booted thugs in smart uniforms with swastikas on their shoulders will rant against good and normalcy.
The Yakuza usually spend most of their time breaking legs, pimping prostitutes, or skimming the profits of their more "legitimate" enterprises. Being right-wing nuts is a part-time occupation for them.
So in other words they are the bottom rung of the corporate ladder.
Bob
__________________
My Gallery
1 Week Ago #30
jonmanjiro
BFNM
jonmanjiro is offline
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Yokohama, Japan
Posts: 3,161
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nikon Bob
So in other words they are the bottom rung of the corporate ladder.
Bob
No, there are rungs below the yakuza. For example, the misfits that the yakuza collected from the streets to go and work in the cleanup effort at Fukushima Dai-Ichi.
__________________
flickr
1 Week Ago #31
Nikon Bob
camera hunter & gatherer
Nikon Bob is offline
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 3,722
Quote:
Originally Posted by jonmanjiro
No, there are rungs below the yakuza. For example, the misfits that the yakuza collected from the streets to go and work in the cleanup effort at Fukushima Dai-Ichi.
Jez, that ladder goes to the sub basement too. Well, not to make too much light of it but it is a nasty situation for sure. The thin veneer of civilization is just that: thin. No different than other places. Distasteful that Nikon would crumble so easily.
Bob
__________________
My Gallery
No comments:
Post a Comment